By Kurnia · Published November 15, 2026 · Version 1 · 21 min read
Metal polish
alumina as the abrasive with citric acid and ethanol, mineral oil emulsion, flash point, plated metals and scratches, used oily cloths, and handling and storage
A silver-plated teapot in a hotel is polished every week until the yellow color of its base metal shows through on the raised parts, and the used polishing cloths go into the dryer along with the kitchen cloths. This chapter covers two types of metal polish from the side of their chemistry, according to the manufacturer’s safety data sheets for two products of this class: an acidic liquid with alumina abrasive at 30 to 60 percent together with citric acid and ethanol, and a mineral oil emulsion with gas oil and a glycol ether. It covers how an abrasive as hard as corundum lifts tarnish along with the metal itself, why a thin metal coating wears through, the role of the acid and the ban on mixing it with chlorine bleach, the meaning of a flash point of 57 °C, used oily cloths as fuel, health hazards, and handling and storage. Directions for use and a list of metals that may be polished are not given. Replating metal, large spills, and treating a casualty are stated as work for other parties.
In the equipment storeroom of a hotel, silver-plated teapots and trays were polished every week so that they always shone on the buffet table. After more than a year, the raised parts of a teapot handle turned yellowish and would no longer shine, however hard they were rubbed. The silver coating was gone at that spot, and what showed was the base metal. In the same week, the cloths used to polish a stair handrail were washed with the kitchen cloths and then went into the dryer, and a laundry attendant noticed a scorched smell from the pile of cloths that had just been taken out.
Both events came from the same kind of bottle. The abrasive powder in a metal polish does not tell tarnish from the metal underneath it, and its carrier liquid stays behind in the cloth as a material that can burn. Workers need to know what is in that bottle, what is lost from the surface each time it is polished, and where the used cloths go.
Scope
This chapter covers two types of metal polish sold ready to use, namely an acidic liquid containing abrasive powder and an oil emulsion: their contents and pH, how the abrasive and the acid act on tarnish, what that does to plated metals, flash point, used oily cloths, health hazards, and handling and storage. The product data come from the manufacturer’s safety data sheets for two products of this class and apply to those two products only. Other products may differ, so what applies is the label and the safety data sheet of the product in use.
This chapter is study material, not a work instruction. Directions for use, contact time, and a list of metals that may be polished are not given; all of them are read from the product label and the workplace procedure. Polishing cream whose abrasive is quartz, the hardness scale, and testing in a hidden spot are in Chapter 33 on abrasive polishing cream for hard surfaces. How to check a data sheet is in Chapter 26 on reading safety data sheets for cleaning products.
Stainless steel is covered in Chapter 3 · Materials, copper and brass in Chapter 4 · Materials on copper, brass, bronze, and aluminum, and metal plating in Chapter 17 · Materials on metal surface treatment. Emulsions are in Chapter 21 on surfactants, colloids, and emulsions, glycol ethers are in Chapter 29 on glass and mirror cleaners, and hazardous mixtures are in Chapter 25 on chemical reactivity and incompatibility. Fire is covered in Chapter 17 · Buildings & Facilities on fire protection.
Work outside the authority of cleaning staff and building technicians: replating metal whose coating has worn through, polishing antiques or valuable objects, handling large spills, fighting a fire that has already grown, and giving treatment other than first aid. Replating belongs to a plating shop or the equipment supplier, valuable objects belong to a conservator, large spills belong to trained personnel, fires belong to the emergency response team and the fire service, and casualties are handled by a doctor or the emergency services.
Two types of metal polish and what they contain
In 1939 the United States National Bureau of Standards described metal polish as an abrasive material suspended in a liquid or paste vehicle, and wrote that the principal difference between paste polishes and liquid polishes is in the vehicle. The two products whose data sheets this chapter uses differ at exactly that point: the first carries an abrasive in an acidic liquid, the second is an oil with no abrasive.
According to the manufacturer’s safety data sheets for two products of this class, both are sold ready to use for industrial and professional use.
| Item | Abrasive liquid | Oil emulsion |
|---|---|---|
| Form | white liquid, soluble in water | clear light-yellow emulsion, insoluble in water |
| Ingredients and concentrations | aluminum oxide (CAS 1344-28-1) at 30 to 60 percent; alcohols, C12 to C14, ethoxylated (CAS 68439-50-9), ethanol (CAS 64-17-5), and citric acid monohydrate (CAS 5949-29-1) at 1 to 5 percent each | white mineral oil (CAS 8042-47-5) at 30 to 60 percent; gas oil (CAS 64741-44-2) at 30 to 60 percent; 2-(2-butoxyethoxy)ethanol (CAS 112-34-5) at 10 to 30 percent |
| pH | 2.9 to 3.7 for the 100 percent product | 4.5 to 7.5, with no concentration stated |
| Flash point | 57 °C closed cup, with a note that it does not sustain combustion | no figure |
| Written classification | eye irritation category 2B | eye irritation category 2A |
| Storage temperature | 0 to 40 °C | 0 to 50 °C |
| Issued and valid until | August 26, 2025; August 25, 2030 | February 22, 2025; February 21, 2030 |
The relative density of the abrasive liquid is written as 1.28 to 1.33. The concentration ranges on a data sheet cannot all sit at their upper ends: for the oil emulsion, the three upper ends add up to 150 percent (Example 5). Those ranges show the classes of ingredients and their order of magnitude, not a recipe, and this chapter reads them as percent by mass.
Alumina as the abrasive: tarnish, plated metals, and scratches
An abrasive is a hard grain that removes material from a surface by friction. Aluminum oxide, or alumina, occurs in nature as the mineral corundum, a very hard substance used as an abrasive for grinding and polishing. On the Mohs hardness scale, which compares the resistance of materials to scratching, corundum is rated 9, quartz 7, a steel nail 6.5, a knife blade 5.5, and a copper coin 3.5. Alumina grains are harder than the steel nail and the copper coin on that scale, so those grains scratch the metal being polished as well.
Tarnish is discoloration of a bright metal surface caused by a thin film of corrosion products. The United States National Park Service guidance on the care of metal objects, which was written for museum collections, states that cleaning and polishing remove original metal, and that metal cleaners may leave chemical residues that can generate further corrosion. Every polishing takes a thin layer of metal along with the tarnish. On an object made of solid metal, that loss takes a long time to show. On a plated object, what is used up is the coating.
Plating is a thin layer of one metal deposited on the surface of another metal. Silver-plated spoons and chromium-plated faucets belong to this group. The National Bureau of Standards wrote that on chromium-plated, nickel-plated, or silver-plated ware only the mildest abrasive should be used, because the coatings are thin. The life of a coating can be estimated with a simple model:
where is the number of polishings until the coating is gone, is the coating thickness in micrometers, and is the thickness removed by each polishing in micrometers. This model assumes that the wear is even and the same each time. Raised parts and edges wear faster, and the value of depends on the abrasive, the hand pressure, and the cloth, so this formula only shows that a coating has a life (Example 2).
Besides plating, a metal surface may be given a patina, a coating, or a chemical coloring treatment. Layers like those are thin, and an abrasive as hard as corundum can wear them away. For that reason three questions are answered before the bottle is opened: what metal this is, whether it is solid or plated, and whether there is a clear coating on top. If the answers are not certain, the object is not polished with an abrasive product. Testing in a hidden spot is covered in Chapter 33.
Citric acid, surfactant, and ethanol in the abrasive liquid
The abrasive liquid has a pH of 2.9 to 3.7, so the liquid is acidic. Most metal oxides react with acids to form salts, whereas aluminum oxide is very insoluble. The part of the tarnish that is oxide can react with the citric acid in the liquid, while the alumina grains stay intact and work as the abrasive. How acids dissolve oxides is covered in Chapter 31 on rust, scale, and cement residue removers.
The National Bureau of Standards wrote that metal polishes should not contain mineral acids or other materials that may have an injurious effect on metals. Citric acid is a weak organic acid, not a mineral acid, but liquid with a pH of 3 that is left in crevices and engraving stays on the metal after the work is finished.
The ethoxylated alcohol is a nonionic surfactant, the class covered in Chapter 21. Ethanol is an alcohol that evaporates readily and ignites readily; among the listed ingredients, it is the one most likely to give the liquid a flash point.
The acidic nature brings one firm prohibition. The data sheet for the abrasive liquid states that the product must not be mixed with bleach or other products containing chlorine, because chlorine gas will form, and that the product is kept away from oxidizing substances. HSE, the British occupational safety authority, notes that cleaning products containing bleach that are mixed with acidic cleaners give off harmful gases, and gives one short rule: never mix cleaning substances. A washbasin that has just been cleaned with chlorine bleach is rinsed first before its faucet is polished.
Mineral oil emulsion: dissolving soil and leaving a film
An emulsion is a mixture of two liquids that do not dissolve in each other, with one liquid dispersed as fine droplets in the other and kept that way by an emulsifying agent. The second product contains no abrasive powder. It contains white mineral oil, gas oil, and one glycol ether, and the product is insoluble in water. The oil mixes with oily soil such as fingermarks, then stays behind as a thin film on the metal surface.
Three things follow from that property. First, oil that drips makes the floor slippery, so drips under a stair handrail or an elevator door are cleaned up at once, as covered in Chapter 39 · Buildings & Facilities on floors and tiles. Second, NIOSH, the United States occupational safety and health institute, notes that mineral oil is insoluble in water and recommends that skin that has been in contact with it is washed with soap and water. Third, this product is not sprayed into a mist. NIOSH recommends an average limit of 5 mg/m³ and a short-term exposure limit of 10 mg/m³ for mineral oil mist, with the symptoms irritation of the eyes, skin, and respiratory system. The amount that equals that figure is very small (Example 6).
Whether the oil film is suitable for food-contact surfaces is not written on the data sheet; for tableware, what applies is the product label.
Flash point and vapor that can ignite
Flash point is the lowest temperature at which a liquid gives off vapor in sufficient concentration to form an ignitable mixture with air near its surface. The figure is measured with a closed cup or an open cup, and the method is stated together with the figure. The data sheet for the abrasive liquid gives a flash point of 57 °C closed cup.
Two rules use flash point as a dividing line. HSE guidance calls a liquid flammable if its flash point is 60 °C or below, and places a flash point of 23 to 60 °C in category 3 of the classification regulation it refers to. In Indonesia, Kepmenaker 187/1999 (a Minister of Manpower decree) sets the criterion for a flammable liquid at a flash point above 21 °C and below 55 °C, and for a highly flammable liquid at a flash point below 21 °C with a boiling point above 20 °C. As of November 2026 that decree is listed as in force on JDIH Kemnaker, the ministry’s legal documentation site. The figure 57 °C lies inside the category 3 range of the British guidance and slightly above the 55 °C limit of that ministerial decree (Example 3).
A flash point in degrees Fahrenheit, as in United States data, is converted with
where is the temperature in °C and is the temperature in °F. NIOSH lists the flash point of pure ethanol as 55 °F and the flash point of mineral oil as 380 °F open cup. Ethanol in the abrasive liquid is only 1 to 5 percent, and the flash point of the mixture is far above the flash point of pure ethanol.
HSE explains three things that mean a flash point must not be read as a safe limit. A liquid below its flash point can still form an ignitable mixture if it is heated or released as a mist or spray. That liquid can also be readily ignited if it is present as a thin film on a surface or has soaked into absorbent material such as cloth. Water and solvent mixtures and emulsions may release vapor slowly: the vapor is enough for the mixture to be given a flash point, even though the rate of release may be insufficient to sustain combustion. For that reason the abrasive liquid is not used near a naked flame, a cigarette, or a hot surface, and is not applied to metal that is still hot.
The data sheet for the oil emulsion gives no flash point figure. Its ingredients are oils, so that product is treated as a material that can burn and is kept away from flame and heat.
Used oily cloths
After polishing, part of the product has moved into the cloth, and its liquid is spread thinly over the fibers.
HSE guidance asks for cleaning rags and other items contaminated with flammable liquid to be placed in a labeled metal bin with a self-closing metal lid, and for the bin to be emptied at least daily. The reason is that the contents of that bin present a fire hazard and may undergo spontaneous combustion, especially if contaminated with paint residues. The National Bureau of Standards has given similar guidance since 1939: oily and greasy rags are destroyed immediately after use or kept in closed metal containers, and animal and vegetable oils are the most likely to undergo spontaneous combustion. Mineral oil does not belong to those two groups, but a cloth wet with oil is still fuel.
For hotels there is one more route. The British government’s fire risk assessment guide for sleeping accommodation notes that cleaning cloths and mop heads placed in dryers can spontaneously combust if there is any chemical residue left on them. Used polishing cloths are not combined with linen and do not go into a dryer unless the laundry procedure sets out how they are washed; dryers are covered in Chapter 15 · Laundry on drying and finishing. Disposal of contaminated cloths follows the label and Chapter 35 · Water & Water Treatment on B3 waste in hotels, laundries, and workshops.
Health hazards, personal protective equipment, and first aid
The classification written on both data sheets is eye irritation. Splashes to the eyes can happen when the product is poured onto a cloth or when polishing above head height. NIOSH notes that ethanol irritates the eyes, skin, and nose, and that alumina dust irritates the eyes, skin, and respiratory system. For both ethanol and mineral oil mist, its recommendations are that skin contact is prevented, contaminated skin is washed, and wet clothing is removed. Abrasive liquid residue that dries leaves alumina powder behind, and how to remove it is read from the label.
HSE guidance for hospitality workers: the protective clothing provided is worn when handling cleaning substances, eye protection is worn if there is any chance of splashing and when cleaning at eye level or above, gloves are checked for holes and tears, and cleaning substances are only used in well-ventilated areas. The glove type is read from the product’s data sheet.
First aid follows the workplace procedure. NIOSH guidance for the substances in the two products:
- Eyes. The eyes are immediately washed with large amounts of water while occasionally lifting the lower and upper lids, then the casualty gets medical attention immediately.
- Skin. The skin is promptly flushed with water, and oil is washed off with soap and water. Clothing that the liquid has soaked through is removed immediately. If irritation persists after washing, the casualty gets medical attention.
- Inhaled. The casualty is moved to fresh air at once.
- Swallowed. The casualty gets medical attention immediately.
The label or the product’s data sheet is taken to the doctor.
Handling and storage
The manufacturer’s safety data sheets for two products of this class give a storage temperature of 0 to 40 °C for the abrasive liquid and 0 to 50 °C for the oil emulsion. The abrasive liquid is stored away from heat and sources of ignition, away from oxidizing substances, and not together with bleach or chlorine-containing products. A hot storeroom narrows the margin to the flash point (Example 3).
The British government’s fire guide asks for the quantity of dangerous substances to be kept to the smallest amount necessary, for flammable liquids to be locked away, especially when the premises are unoccupied, and for there to be no ignition sources where such liquids are used or stored if their vapor can build up. HSE adds general guidance for cleaning substances: original labeled containers with lids, away from heat, sunlight, and foodstuffs, not transferred into food or drink containers, and spills cleaned up immediately. Small spills are handled according to Chapter 6 · Safety on chemicals in technician work.
Worked example
The figures in the examples below are practice figures, unless their origin is stated. A relative density of 1.305 is used as the midpoint of the range on the data sheet for the abrasive liquid, so one milliliter of that liquid has a mass of 1.305 g.
Example 1: what one bottle of abrasive liquid contains. A 500 mL bottle has a content mass of g. At 30 percent, its alumina is g, and at 60 percent g. Its ethanol is g to g, and its citric acid lies in the same range. Almost one third to three fifths of the content mass of the bottle is abrasive powder, so the sediment at the bottom of the bottle is the abrasive, not dirt.
Example 2: the life of a silver coating. A teapot has a silver coating 5 micrometers thick, and each polishing removes 0.05 micrometers. The coating is gone after polishings. If it is polished once a week, that is years. If the schedule is changed to once a month, its life is years. On the raised parts, the coating is gone sooner than this calculation.
Example 3: flash point in degrees Celsius and the margin to storeroom temperature. The flash point of pure ethanol is °C, below room temperature. The flash point of mineral oil is °C. For the abrasive liquid in a storeroom at 32 °C, the margin to its flash point is °C, and at the upper limit of the storage temperature the margin is °C. Against the two dividing lines, 57 °C lies °C below the limit of the British guidance and °C above the limit of Kepmenaker 187/1999. A figure that close to both lines is treated as a flammable liquid.
Example 4: what a pH of 2.9 to 3.7 means. The hydrogen ion concentration at pH 2.9 is mol/L, and at pH 3.7 it is mol/L. The acidic end of that range is times more concentrated than the other end. Compared with neutral water at pH 7, a liquid at pH 3 has times more hydrogen ions. The ban on mixing it with chlorine bleach comes from this acidic nature.
Example 5: oil in a used cloth. One cloth absorbs 25 g of oil emulsion. The sum of the three upper ends of the concentration ranges, percent, cannot occur. The two oils add up to at least percent, and to at most percent if the glycol ether is at its lower end. That cloth carries g to g of oil. Ten cloths a day carry g to g of oil to the lidded metal bin, which is emptied every day.
Example 6: oil mist in a small room. A linen room measuring 4 m by 3 m by 3 m has a volume of m³. The figure 5 mg/m³ is equaled by mg of mineral oil mist. At a mineral oil content of 30 percent, that corresponds to mg of product, and at 60 percent to mg. Less than one gram of product turned into mist already equals that recommended figure in a room this small.
Stop conditions
- Product gets in the eyes: stop work and rinse immediately with plenty of water. The casualty is taken to a doctor.
- The abrasive liquid meets chlorine bleach, or a sharp smell of chlorine is noticed: leave the room and do not try to neutralize the mixture. The supervisor calls trained personnel or the emergency response team, and anyone short of breath is taken to the emergency services.
- There is a naked flame, a cigarette, or a hot surface where polishing is done, or the metal to be polished is still hot: do not start. The supervisor moves the work or waits until the heat source is out and cold.
- Used polishing cloths are piled up outside the lidded metal bin, feel warm, or smell scorched: keep people away and do not pull the pile apart by hand. The supervisor calls the building’s emergency response team.
- Used polishing cloths are about to be washed with linen or put into a dryer: do not put them in. The laundry supervisor decides according to the written procedure.
- The metal is not identified, is plated, has a clear coating, has a patina, or the object is antique and valuable: do not polish it with an abrasive product. The supervisor contacts the equipment supplier or a conservator.
- The color of the base metal shows, the coating peels, or scratches are visible after the test in a hidden spot: stop. Repair of the surface belongs to a plating shop or the equipment supplier.
- The bottle has no label, the contents have been transferred into a drink bottle, or the safety data sheet is missing or past its validity date: do not use it. The supervisor asks the supplier for clarification.
- The product is about to be used on tableware or a food-contact surface and the label does not mention it: do not use it there. The supervisor asks the supplier whether it is suitable.
- A spill is larger than the local spill kit can handle, or oil runs onto the floor of a guest area: close off that area. Trained personnel do the cleanup.
Common misinterpretations
Guess what’s wrong first, then open the explanation.
Common misconception
Metal polish only cleans; it does not take away any metal.
Why is it wrong?
The abrasive takes a layer of metal along with the tarnish every time it is used. On a plated object, that coating has a life.
Common misconception
A flash point of 57 °C means the liquid is safe up to that temperature.
Why is it wrong?
A flash point is not a safe limit. A liquid below its flash point can still be readily ignited if it has soaked into a cloth or is sprayed as a mist.
Common misconception
A white, scented liquid is bound to be neutral.
Why is it wrong?
Its pH is 2.9 to 3.7. The liquid is acidic and must not meet chlorine bleach.
Common misconception
Polishing cloths can be washed and dried with the other cloths.
Why is it wrong?
Cleaning cloths that still hold chemical residue can spontaneously combust inside a dryer. Used polishing cloths have their own route.
Common misconception
Every shiny metal can be polished with the same bottle.
Why is it wrong?
Chromium, nickel, and silver plating, patina, and clear coatings are thin, and an abrasive as hard as corundum can wear them away. The type of surface is confirmed first.
Links to other chapters
Chapter 5 · Materials on mechanical properties and their testing explains the hardness of metals. Chapter 43 on hand soaps and hand sanitizers covers the flash point of high-strength ethanol, and Chapter 34 · Water & Water Treatment on used cooking oil, grease, and used oil covers the storage of oily materials. The ban on mixing acids with bleach is set out in Chapter 30 on acid bathroom cleaners, and the choice of protection in Chapter 5 · Safety on personal protective equipment.
Exercises and worked solutions
The figures in the problems are for practice.
Try to answer first, then open the worked solution.
A 750 mL bottle contains abrasive liquid with a relative density of 1.305. How many grams of alumina does it contain at 30 percent and at 60 percent?
Check my answer
See the worked solution
The content mass of the bottle is g. Its alumina is g to g. Almost one third to three fifths of the content mass of the bottle is abrasive.
A solvent has a flash point of 100 °F closed cup. What is its flash point in °C, and where does it stand against the limits of the HSE guidance and Kepmenaker 187/1999?
Check my answer
See the worked solution
Its flash point is °C. That figure lies between 23 and 60 °C, so it falls in category 3 under the HSE guidance, and it lies above 21 °C and below 55 °C, so it meets the Kepmenaker 187/1999 criterion for a flammable liquid. In a storeroom at 32 °C the margin is only °C.
A silver-plated spoon looks yellowish on the back of the bowl after two years of weekly polishing. What has happened, and what is the decision?
Check my answer
See the worked solution
The silver coating is gone at the part that is rubbed most often, and what shows is the base metal. Polishing harder only enlarges the worn area, so polishing is stopped and the supervisor decides between replating by a plating shop and replacement.
A chromium coating 8 micrometers thick is polished twice a week, and each polishing removes 0.04 micrometers. How many weeks until the coating is gone according to the model?
Check my answer
See the worked solution
The number of polishings is . At twice a week, that is weeks. The model assumes even wear, so edges and corners are gone sooner than this figure.
A worker puts cloths used with the oil emulsion into the washing machine with the kitchen cloths, then into the dryer. What is wrong?
Check my answer
See the worked solution
Cleaning cloths that still hold chemical residue can spontaneously combust inside a dryer, and washing does not necessarily remove all of their oil. Used polishing cloths are collected in a lidded metal bin and handled according to the laundry procedure.
A washbasin has just been cleaned with chlorine bleach and has not been rinsed. A worker is about to polish its faucet straight away with the abrasive liquid. What must be done?
Check my answer
See the worked solution
The abrasive liquid is acidic, and an acid that meets chlorine bleach gives off chlorine gas. The washbasin and the faucet are first rinsed with water until clean. If the smell of chlorine is already noticeable, the worker leaves and reports to the supervisor.
References
External sources
- Washing, Cleaning, and Polishing Materialsnvlpubs.nist.gov
- Chemistry 2eopenstax.org
- Appendix O: Curatorial Care of Metal Objectsnps.gov
- Mohs Hardness Scalenps.gov
- Safe use and handling of flammable liquidshse.gov.uk
- NIOSH Pocket Guide to Chemical Hazardscdc.gov
- Fire safety risk assessment: sleeping accommodation (accessible)gov.uk
- Safe use of cleaning substances in the hospitality industryhse.gov.uk
- Keputusan Menteri Tenaga Kerja R.I. No. Kep. 187/MEN/1999 tentang Pengendalian Bahan Kimia Berbahaya di Tempat Kerjajdih.kemnaker.go.id
Revision history
| Date | Version | Change |
|---|---|---|
| November 15, 2026 | 1 | First published |
How to cite
Kurnia (2026). Metal polish: alumina as the abrasive with citric acid and ethanol, mineral oil emulsion, flash point, plated metals and scratches, used oily cloths, and handling and storage. ARSTEMA Academy. Revised November 15, 2026. arstema.com/en/academy/konsep/poles-logam-alumina-sebagai-pengikis-dengan-asam-sitrat-dan-etanol-emulsi-minyak-mineral-titik-nyala-logam-berlapis-dan-goresan-kain-bekas-berminyak-serta-penanganan-dan-penyimpanan
Self-check · 3 questions
Check your understanding before moving on
Write your answer in your own words, then compare it with the worked solution from this chapter’s exercises. The system doesn’t judge open answers as right or wrong; you decide which parts you’ve understood.
A 750 mL bottle contains abrasive liquid with a relative density of 1.305. How many grams of alumina does it contain at 30 percent and at 60 percent?
A solvent has a flash point of 100 °F closed cup. What is its flash point in °C, and where does it stand against the limits of the HSE guidance and Kepmenaker 187/1999?
A silver-plated spoon looks yellowish on the back of the bowl after two years of weekly polishing. What has happened, and what is the decision?
Nearby chapters
Reading order by shelf: Chemistry · Chapter 48.
Reading order by shelf: Chemistry · Chapter 46.